Cookies are the most popular snack in America and millions of people consume them worldwide. With this 
Baking a batch of cookies, just like any other form of baking requires you to be very precise with your recipe and also have all the tools ready in perfect condition. However, when you do start baking cookies, the saddest thing that can happen is realizing that your baking tray isn’t fit for use. It may have been scratched, stained or dented. You can still use such a cookie sheet to bake your batch, but they will not turn out good, they may end up unevenly cooked or may stick to the baking sheet and may not come off without crumbling. This makes it essential to get a high-quality cookie sheet as not baking a great batch can dishearten even the most enthusiastic bakers.
Cookie sheets come in various shapes, sizes and material types. This gives you a large variety of cookie sheets to choose from. The basic two categories are rimmed and unrimmed sheets and they further divide depending on other properties. Both rimmed and unrimmed cookie sheets have their own benefits and drawbacks and the kind you buy depends on what you need it for and how you plan on using it.
Read our latest guide about the best home deep fryers.
But first, it’s important to know about cookie sheets before going out to buy one, so it’s a good idea to learn about their basics.
The Basics of Cookie Sheets
Cookie sheets are often confused with baking sheets, and their names are often used interchangeably, but it is important to know that they are not the same. Baking sheets have rimmed edges and usually come in the half-sheet size – 13”x18”. These fit in most ovens and allow room for even air circulation throughout the dish. However, these baking sheets are built to work better in commercial kitchens where they are used for baking, roasting, toasting, 
Cookie sheets have flat edges with slits on the sides to be used like handles to assist you in lifting the sheet. They have a large flat surface to help cook large batches of cookies in one go and even allow rotation inside the oven. Their rimless design makes it much easier to slide cookies off the pan after baking. It should be noted that cookie sheets are not versatile as they don’t have rimmed edges to prevent spills from sauces and oils.
However, both are great for baking cookies. Besides the usage, you also need to know what to look for in a cookie sheet before buying one. So, lets take a look at some qualities which all great cookie sheets possess.
Qualities of the Best Cookie Sheets
When you’re looking for the best cookie sheet, you may want to look into the qualities some of the best cookie sheers out there possess. This will help you know what to look for. But keep in mind that what’s good for someone may not be good for you and you should use these qualities as a measure for your case and needs.
Heft
The heft of your cookie sheet is a property you can judge by touching it. However, for precision, it is recommended that you look at the gauge mentioned. The gauge scale is a retrogressive scale and that means that higher numbers represent lower thickness. Measuring the heft of your cookie tray is important as a sheet that is too thin may curve or bend in high temperatures. So, it’s important to pick a sheet with a lower gauge. On the other hand, it’s also important to remember to not go overboard as a thicker sheet may be more resistant to heat.
Size
Most ovens have enough space to fit a 22” wide baking tray inside and hence a cookie sheet that is 13”x18” is considered ideal as this gives enough room for all the air around to circulate. Also, this size is large enough to accommodate a big batch of cookies. And as a bonus, this size allows the parchment paper to fit inside like a glove without the need for any tiresome trimming.
However, it is important to note that if you have a larger oven, then you can also go for a 26”x17” baking tray as it 
Read our complete guide about the best ceramic frying pans.
Material
When you need to decide upon the material, you get various different options to choose from. These are non-stick, aluminum, carbon steel, and insulated.
Non-Stick
Non-Stick sheets are made by coating a thin sheet of steel with PTFE or Teflon and these make cleaning the sheet after baking feel like a breeze. These also prevent the cookies from sticking to the sheet and makes cookie removal much smoother and crumble free.
However, in recent years, studies have shown that some of these materials can actually release toxic gases into your food when heated and hence should be avoided if possible.
There are other non-stick options that include a super smooth sheet of metal, etc. that provides a similar experience without the toxicity.
Aluminum
Aluminum is one of the most popular materials for cookie sheets among hobbyists and home bakers. This is due to its lightweight and durability. Aluminum can sometimes get discolored or stained while in the oven, but as long as you keep it out of the dishwasher, you should be okay as then the stains won’t stay for long. Also, while using aluminum, it is important to use parchment paper or oil to prevent your cookies from sticking to the sheet.
Carbon Steel
Carbon steel isn’t a good heat conductor. It can take a very long time to get to the right temperature and takes a long time to cool down as well. This makes carbon steel a bit unfit for baking as while using it, you wil
Insulated
Insulated cookie sheets are engineered to provide even heating throughout your batch. This amazing advantage comes at the cost of timing as these cookie sheets take a lot of time to heat up in the oven or to cool down after baking is over. Despite this, they are perfect for baking cookies, brownies, breads, pizzas, etc. and you are sure to be satisfied with every batch.
Now that you know about what to look for in a cookie sheet, lets take a look at some of the best cookie sheets out there. You can feel free to select one of these or to choose your own from the market.
TOP 15 BEST COOKIE SHEETS IN 2022
Picture |
Name |
Features |
Price |
Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Picture |
Name |
Feature |
Price |
Rating |
 |
1. Boxiki Kitchen Nonstick Baking Sheet |
Non-Stick, high gauge | $$ | 4.8 |
 |
2. Rachael Ray 47576 3-Piece Cookie Sheet |
Bold-colored, extra-wide grippy handlesr | $$ | 4.8 |
 |
3. Wilton Ever-Glide Non-Stick Cookie Baking Sheet Set |
support both baking and cooking | $$ | 4.7 |
 |
4. GRIDMANN 13″ x 18″ Commercial Grade Aluminum Cookie Sheet |
Easy to clean – Hand wash only | $$ | 4.6 |
 |
5. Fungun Baking Sheet with Cooling Rack |
easy clean and dishwasher safe | $$ | 4.6 |
 |
6. USA Pan Bakeware Cookie Sheet |
Works with all oven sizes | $$ | 4.5 |
 |
7. Wildone Baking Sheet with Silicone Mat |
Suitable for both ovens and freezers | $$ | 4.5 |
 |
8. TeamFar Baking Sheet |
Ideal for amateur bakers | $$ | 4.5 |
 |
9. AirBake Natural 2 Pack Cookie Sheet |
10 year warranty | $$ | 4.4 |
 |
10. P&P CHEF Large Baking Sheet |
non toxic 18/0 stainless steel | $$ | 4.3 |
 |
11. Calphalon Nonstick Bakeware, Baking Sheet |
Multipurpose | $$ | 4.2 |
 |
12. AirBake Nonstick Cookie Sheet |
Micro-Dome technology | $$ | 4.1 |
 |
13. Wilton Supplies 5-Piece Essential Cookie Sheet |
oven safe to 400°F | $$ | 4.0 |
 |
14.Circulon Nonstick Bakeware 2-Piece Bakeware Set |
PFOA-free metal utensil safe | $$ | 4.0 |
 |
15. Wilton 15 x 21-Inch 2105-0109 Cookie Pan |
10-year warranty
|
$$ | 3.9 |
1. Boxiki Kitchen Nonstick Baking Sheet
The Boxiki Kitchen Non-Stick Baking Sheet is an excellent option when you’re looking to buy a cookie sheet that will 
Gauge
This non-stick pan comes built hefty and sturdy enough to withstand the high temperatures in your oven. It is made of a heavy gauge stainless steel that works perfectly even at 445° F and can even be used in refrigerators, and deep freezers. The sheet is also quite heavy as it is made of 100% stainless steel and not of aluminum.
Size
The size of this cookie sheet is ideal to fit most household ovens and still leave space for air to circulate freely and radiate heat throughout your batch of fresh cookies. Its 14”x11” measurements show that it can also be rotated inside your oven, if it has that feature available. Besides, you can easily fit a 14”x11” parchment paper inside the tray to allow easy cleaning (which shouldn’t be a problem even without the parchment paper as it is a non-stick tray).
Material
The cookie sheet is made of professional baking grade 100% stainless steel that lets you work without the fear of damaging it. It has been approved by the FDA and is perfectly safe for using to bake for your family. The stainless steel is extremely smooth and that is what gives it its non-stick surface without the use of any harmful chemical coating. Moreover, the baking sheet is also free from any aluminum fillers, and is made from genuine steel.
Rim Type
The Boxiki Kitchen Nonstick Baking Sheet has quite a depth to it and is rimmed on all edges. This helps make the sheet versatile enough to handle basic cooking processes such as baking, braising, roasting, etc. The rim is designed to prevent juices, gravies, and oils from flowing over into the oven.
Usability
As mentioned above, this is an extremely versatile cookie sheet that can be used to even cook foods in your home. You can use it for roasting up your thanksgiving dinner, or to even braise a fresh fish. The rims on the edges will keep the juices inside, while the smooth steel ensures easy cleaning afterwards without compromising on health.
Pros:
- Thick stainless steel and big size
- No toxic chemical coating/ aluminum fillers
- Extremely versatile and ready for cooking
- Non-Stick, high gauge, can take high temperatures
Cons:
- A bit heavy for lifting with ease
2. Rachael Ray 47576 3-Piece Cookie Sheet
The Rachael Ray 47576 is an amazing set of 3 different sizes of cookie sheets, perfect for using at home to bake and 
Gauge
The Rachael Ray pans are made of thick and tough stainless steel that comes ready to withstand the high temperatures of your oven without any warping. The sheets are made of a heavy gauge stainless steel that can take up to 500°F in the oven. You can tell by their density that they are made from 100% steel.
Size
The pans come in three different sizes – small, medium, and large and are ready to make your baking/cooking experience a whole lot easier. You can use the pans to bake different sized batches of cookies and you can be sure that with three different sizes ready at your disposal, you will always have the right size for any oven – whether you’re baking at home, at a friend’s place or even at a competition.
Material
The three cookie sheets are made of high quality, baking grade stainless steel, and are hardwired for durability. They are dense and may seem heavy because of this, but they are still light enough to lift and carry till the oven. The stainless steel is coated with a super thin layer of non-stick material which helps make your cookies slide off the pan with ease. This coating is extremely thin and non-toxic and the cookie sheets are considered safe for use by the FDA.
Rim Type
The sheets are rimmed on all edges and this helps in keeping the juices and gravies from your cooking dishes stay in the pan. This rim, however, is not deep and will still let you slide off your cookies with ease.
Usability
The Rachael Ray pans can be used for a variety of activities ranging from cooking and braising to roasting and baking. This ensures that your pans are ready for use whenever you need them. Besides, a portion of the proceedings go to Yum-Ro, a non-profit by Rachael Ray.
Pros:
- Sturdy and can tolerate high temperatures
- Comes in 3 different sizes (1 set contains 3)
- Non-stick, yet food safe stainless steel
- Can be used for a variety of cooking/baking processes
Cons:
- A bit heavier than aluminum sheets
3. Wilton Ever-Glide Non-Stick Cookie Baking Sheet Set
This professional grade set of cookie sheets is perfect for use at home and offers two pieces in two sizes each.
Gauge
Wilton has maintained its name with the Ever-Glide Non-Stick Cookie Sheets as they are all made of heavy gauge steel. These pans are meant to take the hot temperatures of your oven without warping or bending in the heat. Also, you can safely put them in the refrigerator or the deep freezer if you need to work on a cold dish. Besides that, these pans are dishwasher safe and can even be used in the dishwasher.
Size
The Ever-Glide set comes ready with two different sizes, and two pieces of each size. The sizes are – 15.25”x10.25” (medium), and 17.25”x11.25” (large). This is perfect for when you need to bake large batches of cookies and other baked goods and also cook a meal at the same time. Also, having two separate sizes is great as it lets you have more freedom in cooking, irrespective of the size of your oven. The pans have been sized to cook/bake your meal while leaving enough room to allow air to flow throughout inside the oven in the respective oven sizes.
Material
The cookie sheets are made of professional baker grade stainless steel which is built for durability in the high temperatures of your oven. The steel is hardwired to not warp, or change color in the heat, and also to work even after being placed in the dishwasher. These steel plates are as dense as you would expect 100% steel to be and are hence quite heavy. They are also coated with a thin layer of non-stick material to allow easy cleaning and sliding.
Rim Type
The sheets are shallow rimmed and hence can prevent small amounts of juices from roasting from overflowing, and at the same time can let you slide off your cookies with ease.
Usability
These baking sheets are very versatile and can be used for cooking, roasting and baking for all dishes in your home. These are even suitable for professional kitchens and competitions and will never let you down anytime.
Pros:
- Durable and can tolerate heat without warping
- Versatile to support both baking and cooking
- Non-Stick and easy to clean
- Safe for ovens, freezers and dishwashers
Cons:
- Cannot be used for braising
4. GRIDMANN 13″ x 18″ Commercial Grade Aluminum Cookie Sheet
The Grifmann 13”x18” is a commercial grade cookie sheet that will always be ready when you need it.
Gauge
The Gridmann 13”x18” is a heavy grade, 18-gauge aluminum pan. It is specially made to tolerate high oven temperatures without warping, a feature that is not often seen in aluminum cookie sheets. The cookie sheet is also extremely lightweight than similar sheets of steel because of aluminum’s low density. This also gives it the ability to cook a large number of batches consecutively without showing any signs of wear and tear.
Size
The cookie sheet comes decently sized at a baker’s half size – 13”x18”. With this size, you can use it in your home oven while leaving enough room for air to flow freely around the batch to cook it properly. The baker’s half size can fit a medium sized batch of cookies or other baked goods and if you have a large oven, you can even fir two of them simultaneously to cook even larger batches faster for a special occasion.
Material
The Gridmann Commercial Grade Aluminum Baking Sheet is made from 100% pure and sturdy aluminum. This makes it especially good for baking since aluminum is a really good conductor of heat, even better than steel. The sturdy aluminum pan has rims that are reinforced with galvanized wire to allow for an even longer life, and the whole sheet is also very lightweight. It, however, does not have a non-stick coating and needs to be oiled or covered in baking paper.
Rim Type
The rims of the baking sheet are reinforced with a 1.0 mm thick galvanized aluminum wire to make it even more durable and rust resistant. The pan is also very deep to allow you to cook and braise meals without worrying about the juices overflowing from the pan.
Usability
This baking sheet serves many purposes as it can be used for cooking, braising, roasting, as well as baking. The rims of the baking sheet prevent juices, gravies and marinades from flowing over the edges and let you cook your meals without having to worry about a mess in your oven.
Pros:
- Lightweight and durable
- Even heating
- Made of commercial grade aluminum
- Multipurpose bakeware
Cons:
- No non-stick feature
5. Fungun Baking Sheet with Cooling Rack
The Fungun Baking Sheet Set is great for when you need to bake something within a deadline, and it serves as a 
Gauge
The Fungun Baking Sheet is made of heavy gauge stainless steel that is meant to take high temperatures without warping. Its cooling and roasting rack is also made of the same stainless steel and will not show discoloration or signs of wear in the high temperatures of your oven. The stainless steel is also rust resistant, and food safe. It is, however, heavier than aluminum counterparts, however, it’s perfect gauge makes up for the low conductivity of steel when compared with aluminum.
Size
The set contains 8 baking sheets – 2 sheets of each size. The sizes are – 16”, 12”, 10”, and 9”. These sizes are perfect for everyone as you can use whichever size you need depending on your oven size as well as your current needs. This makes the set great for competitions as well as for baking on special occasions at a friend’s place. The baking sheets can also be pared together to cook even larger batches of baked goods, and hence you get two of each size.
Material
All 8 of the sheets are made of heavy gauge, baking grade stainless steel which is resistant to warping in high temperatures. The rims of the sheets are reinforced with special wire, whereas the cooling and roasting racks are made of the same grade stainless steel. The stainless-steel use here is rust resistant and hence, you can use it to cook dishes that contain juices, or gravies without the fear of ruining your pan.
Rim Type
The pans contain a reinforced wire rim to enhance durability. The rims are made of dense stainless steel and are meant to prevent spilling. They are also made to last with food that contain juices and gravies without rusting and the rims are not sharp to avoid accidental cuts, etc. The pans are also deep enough to avoid spilling the liquids out when you’re braising or roasting a delicious meal.
Usability
The baking sheets can serve multiple purposes and also feature roasting and cooling racks to aid in your cooking processes and to cool your baked foods faster when you need to meet a deadline.
Pros:
- Multi-purpose, with cooling and roasting racks
- Durable, and rust resistant stainless steel
- Even cooking, heavy gauge baking sheets
- 2 baking sheets in 4 sizes each
Cons:
- No non-stick coating or smoothness
6. USA Pan Bakeware Cookie Sheet
The USA Pan Bakeware Cookie Sheet is made from an aluminized steel and is coated with Americoat to give it non-
Gauge
The USA Pan Bakeware Cookie Sheet is made of a heavy gauge, high grade aluminized steel to tolerate high temperatures without warping or showing any discoloration. The sheets come with a lifetime warranty which clearly shows the confidence USA Pan has in them. They are as durable as steel while being much lighter because of the special grade aluminized steel used.
Size
The cookie sheet comes in one size – 13”x18”, which is widely considered as the baker’s half and it allows you to cook large batches of cookies in the oven while also leaving enough room to let air flow and cook the food evenly. The size is also great for larger ovens as in that case, you can fit two of these sheets and bake an even larger batch. The size is also standard and accepted in competitions and can fit almost all ovens, so you can carry it with you when you wish to bake with a friend.
Material
The material used in the sheets is specially designed aluminized steel which combines the toughness and heat resistance of steel with the lightweight and even conductivity of aluminum, giving you the best of both worlds. The sheet is also coated with USA Pan’s patented non-stick coating called Americoat. Americoat is free of toxins and will keep your food safe for your children to enjoy.
Rim Type
The rim in the baking sheet is thick and made of reinforced metal to allow for an extended durability and prevents juices and other liquids from flowing off the sheet and into your oven. This allows you to cook, and braise food without having to worry about cleaning up a mess in your oven.
Usability
The baking sheet can be used for baking, cooking, roasting as well as braising. Its non-stick coating allows easy cleanup while the rim keeps liquids from flowing over the edges.
Pros:
- Non-Stick, non-toxic surface
- Durable aluminized steel
- Works with all oven sizes
- Multipurpose
Cons:
- Small handle size
7. Wildone Baking Sheet with Silicone Mat
The Wildone Baking Sheet is an excellent baking companion and can even assist you in baking contests.
Gauge
The baking sheets are made of a high quality, 18-gauge stainless steel material that is hardwired to tolerate high temperatures in your oven. The baking sheets can take temperatures up to 450°F and can even be placed in the deep freezer in temperatures as low as – 40°F. This lets you bake both hot and cold desserts as well as a perfect batch of cookies.
Size
The set contains two 12”x16” baking sheets along with two 11”x15” baking mats and this gives you more freedom to bake your favorite foods. The sheets can fir any average sized oven while leaving room for air to flow around freely and give even heat to your food. The baking mats are designed to fit on top of the baking sheets and provide a non-stick layer instead of oil or parchment paper. Also, if you have a larger oven or a full-sized oven, you can fit in both trays simultaneously and bake larger batches of cookies faster.
Material
The baking sheets are made of a high grade, stainless steel material and are not coated with any toxic non-stick coating. This makes them safe for use while baking for children. The sheets are built to tolerate high temperatures without warping and they accomplish this perfectly. They come with high-quality silicone mats that allow you to bake your desserts without using oil or parchment paper.
Rim Type
The baking sheets are deep and have rims on all edges to prevent juices from flowing out and into your oven. This can let you braise or roast your meals without having to worry about cleaning up a huge mess in your oven afterwards.
Usability
The sheets are designed for baking, but if you use them without the silicone, you can use them to braise, roast, or cook your meals and are easy to clean afterwards.
Pros:
- Easy to clean and non-toxic
- Durable and avoid warping
- Suitable for both ovens and freezers
- Come with silicone baking mats
Cons:
- Heavy to lift and small handle support
8. TeamFar Baking Sheet
The TeamFar Baking Sheet is a premium pan for any baking enthusiast and will help you make evenly baked cookies
Gauge
The cookie sheets are made of a high-grade, 18-gauge stainless steel material which is built to last. The set contains two sheets and both can tolerate high temperatures without warping or bending in the heat. The sheets also do not show any signs of discoloration and are quite heavy. The rims are made from the same material instead of a reinforced wire.
Size
The two sheets are both 12”x16” which makes them perfect for the average home oven. This product is made keeping amateur bakers and home chefs in mind and can fit most home ovens while also leaving room for air to circulate around the baked goods and give them even heating. If you have a large oven, you can even fit two of these sheets at once and bake an even larger batch of baked goods at once.
Material
The sheets are made of high-grade stainless steel which is FDA approved and non-toxic. It is also not coated with any non-stick coating to avoid toxicity. This makes the pan perfectly suited for baking with at home. It is also resistant to high temperatures and will not warp or discolor, and does not rust since it is stainless steel.
Rim Type
The baking sheet has a deep 1” rim which lets you cook, braise, roast or bake your choice of food without worrying about juices flowing over the edges and making a mess inside your oven. This makes the sheet ideal for homes, however, the baking sheets do not have reinforced metal rims which may crack after a long while.
Usability
The pans are all multipurpose and let you cook and bake all sorts of oven foods without stressing about toxicity or messes. However, they do not have a non-stick coating which may make them a bit harder to clean.
Pros:
- Food-safe stainless steel
- Works well with ovens and freezers
- Fits almost all home ovens
- Ideal for amateur bakers
Cons:
- Rims aren’t reinforced and may crack with time
- No non-stick coating
9. AirBake Natural 2 Pack Cookie Sheet
The T-Fal AirBake Natural 2 Pack Cookie Sheet is a revolutionary design in the bakeware industry.
Gauge
The pans are made of a heavy gauge aluminum sheet which works well in temperatures up to 400°F and do not get discolored easily. Since the sheets are made of aluminum, they are very light and easy to lift and hold. The aluminum used is also an excellent heat conductor and evenly bakes every batch of cookies. However, the sheet may bend in high temperatures so repeated use should be avoided. However, they are dishwasher safe and can also be refrigerated.
Size
The two sheets are sized as 14”x16” and this medium size perfectly fits in almost every oven. The sheets have a 1” raised lid on one side that allows for easy holding. Each sheet is made of two thin sheets joined together with an air cavity in between them. This air cavity helps evenly heat your cookies and also prevents the top sheet from getting too hot and burning the cookies.
Material
The baking sheets are made from sturdy, 100% aluminum – strong and durable metal. The sheets do not easily rust or warp unless left too wet or too hot for too long. The patented ‘micro-dome’ inside the cookie sheets is perfect for making well-made, golden cookies. However, the aluminum used here is not meant to be used in very high temperatures as it can warp slightly and repeated warping can cause it to crack or get damaged. The aluminum is smoothened out to give the pan some non-stick properties.
Rim Type
The cookie sheet does not have a rim on all edges. It just has a raised rim on one edge of the tray to allow for easy handling. Due to this reason, this baking sheet is not suitable for baking wet mixtures or braising, cooking or roasting dishes that involve juices.
Usability
This cookie sheet is meant to be used only for baking cookies and any other sort of cooking should be avoided or the juices may flow off into your oven and create a hard to clean mess.
Pros:
- High-grade, food safe aluminum
- Evenly bakes cookies with patented ‘micro-dome’
- Raised handle for easy handling
- Size fit for almost all home ovens
Cons:
- May crack or warp in high heat
10. P&P CHEF Large Baking Sheet
The P&P CHEF Large Baking Sheet is an amazing baking sheet and is built to last you a long time.
Gauge
These 18-gauge baking sheets are made from high grade stainless steel and are built to last. The sheets can take high temperatures with minimum warping or bending. They are hardwired to withstand these temperatures without letting discoloration ruin their aesthetics and while evenly baking your cookies. This ensures that you’ll get the perfect golden-brown batch every time. The pans have a moderate weight despite their heavy construction.
Size
The size of the baking sheets is 12”x16” and they are perfectly suited for most home ovens. The set contains 3 sheets and you can use them to bake large batches of cookies at once. These sheets are sized in accordance with the average oven in mind to allow airflow while baking to ensure that the cookies are evenly baked.
Material
The sheets are all made from high quality stainless steel and are completely food safe. They are not coated with any layer to give them non-stick abilities; and even though this may make cleanup difficult, it is healthier than using a coating of toxic chemicals.
Rim Type
The cookie sheets have a 1” depth and are rimmed on all sides. This helps prevent liquids from baking or cooking from flowing over into your pan.
Usability
The sheets are designed to be multipurpose and can be used for cooking, braising, baking, or even roasting. This is accomplished by their deep rims, it allows you to cook in peace and not worry about making a mess with the liquids in your cooking.
Pros:
- Multipurpose and deep rimmed
- Durable and lightweight, stainless steel
- 12”x16” to fit most ovens and also allow air circulation
- Set of 3
Cons:
- No non-stick features
11. Calphalon Nonstick Bakeware, Baking Sheet
This heavy gauge bakeware will last you a lifetime.
Gauge
The Calphalon Nonstick Bakeware is made from heavy gauge steel and is designed to take high temperatures without warping or bending. The cookie sheet heats up your cookies evenly to allow them to come out golden-brown and evenly cooked. The pan is also designed to not overheat in order to prevent cookies from burning.
Size
The set has two sheets of 12”x17” each and both are perfectly sized for most home ovens. The sheets are also of an ideal brownie making size if you ever wish to make brownies with them. They both can fit a large oven simultaneously to cook large batches even faster. Also, this size allows air to freely circulate in your oven while baking to provide even heat on top as well.
Material
The baking sheets are made from toughened steel which is meant to take high temperatures without bending or warping. The steel sheet is coated with a non-stick layer which is non-toxic and FDA approved. The rims are made from reinforced wires to give more strength to the baking sheet.
Rim Type
The sheets have deep rims and the rimmed edges are made from reinforced wire. These rims function as boundaries for when you need to bake a cake, brownies, or cook a meal that involved liquids. The rim will prevent them from flowing into your oven while baking/cooking.
Usability
The pan is multipurpose and can be used for baking a variety of deserts including cakes and brownies. You can also use it to roast or braise meats and cook any oven-based dish.
Pros:
- Durable, stainless steel
- Non-toxic non-stick coating
- Works in almost all ovens
- Multipurpose
Cons:
- Heavier than most baking sheets
12. AirBake Nonstick Cookie Sheet
The T-Fal AirBake Nonstick Cookie Sheet is an amazing baking companion for the cookie enthusiasts.
Gauge
The cookie sheet is made from two 18-gauge, high grade aluminum sheets. They are combined together with an air pocket in between, and then welded together. The air pocket serves the function of preventing the top sheet from over-heating in order to prevent burning the baked goods. The air pocket is patented Micro-Dome by T-Fla and helps provide even heat to the cookies. It also decreases baking time by up to 15 minutes so you would need to take that into account in your recipe timings.
Size
The sheets are decently sized as 14”x16” and will fit most average home ovens. The best part, however is that if you have a larger oven, you can fit both the sheets at once in order to bake a larger batch of cookies. The sheets have been designed to not allow air circulation as the micro-dome renders it useless.
Material
The sheets are made of 18-gauge, high grade aluminum, however are not very good at handling heat. They may warp, bend or even crack if left in high temperatures for too long and hence must not be used repeatedly.
Rim Type
These cookie sheets are rimless and cannot handle liquids. They do however, have a raised side in order to provide a grip while holding them.
Usability
The AirBake sheets are only good for baking cookies and similar baked goods that do not involve liquids as they cannot stop them from flowing off the edge.
Pros:
- High grade steel and are food-safe
- Set contains 2 Airbake Sheets
- Non-Stick coating
- Bakes evenly browned cookies with innovative micro-dome
Cons:
- Cannot take high temperatures
13. Wilton Supplies 5-Piece Essential Cookie Sheet
The Wilton Supplies Cookie baking Set is all you’ll ever need to make perfect, golden-brown cookies.
Gauge
The sheets are made of heavy gauge steel and have a reinforced coating on top. This lets the sheets withstand temperatures up to 400°F. They can also be washed in the dishwasher and are safe for deep freezing your desserts. The set also includes a toughened cooling grid to help cool down your cookies even faster and it is made from the same stainless steel. The sheets evenly cook and brown your cookies so that you get the perfect batch every time.
Size
The set comes with 3 baking sheets and they are sized as – 9.25”x13.25”, 10.25”x15.25”, and 11.5”x17.5”. These sizes go well with almost any home oven and you may also be able to fit in two or more of the sheets at once into a large oven while baking a large batch. The sizes are also standard for competitions and can be used while baking at a friend’s place too.
Material
All three sheets are made of reinforced stainless steel and can easily take both high and low temperatures without warping or bending. The sheets also do not discolor or rust and can last you for decades. The grid that comes along with the sheets is made from the same material and is equally durable. They are not non-stick sheets but do come with a free roll or Wilton Parchment Paper.
Rim Type
All three sheets have a depth of 1” and can hence be used to make dishes that involve liquids and they won’t let the liquids spill or flow off the edge into your oven while baking.
Usability
Due to the high rms, the sheets are well suited for baking, braising, roasting and cooking oven-based recipes. With these amazing sheets, you’ll not have to worry about making a mess in your oven.
Pros:
- Works well in temperatures up to 400°F
- Durable, reinforced steel
- Toughened cooling grid
- Multipurpose
Cons:
- Heavy and no non-stick coating
14. Circulon Nonstick Bakeware 2-Piece Bakeware Set
Circulon’s Nonstick Bakeware is meant to impress and can bake even, golden-brown cookies.
Gauge
The pan is made from heavy gauge, carbon steel and it can work well in temperatures up to 450°F. The carbon steel offers even heat distribution and can bassist you in making the perfect batch of cookies every time. The pan is also reinforced with warp-resistant rolled edges to make it safe for repeated oven use, without having to stress about damaging.
Size
The Circulon Nonstick Bakeware comes with two sheets – each sized as a baker’s half and are ready to be used in almost any average home oven. If you have a larger oven, you may even be able to fit both the sheets at once and bake a larger batch of cookies. The size is also standard for competitions and you can carry it with you while going to bake at a friend’s place.
Material
Both the sheets used in the set are made from reinforced carbon steel and are durable enough to withstand high temperatures without bending or warping. The sheets are also covered with a POFA free non-stick coating to help in easy cookie removal and easy cleanup.
Rim Type
The sheets are 1” deep with rolled edges to help provide extra strength. The rims will keep liquids from flowing off; and hence, you can use the sheets for baking cakes, and cooking with recipes that require liquids or marinades.
Usability
The rims of the sheets allow them to be used for a wide variety of cooking processes and can be used to even cook meals that involve gravies and juices. You can use them for braising, roasting, baking and cooking.
Pros:
- High-grade and durable carbon steel
- POFA free non-stick coating
- Multipurpose
- Rolled rims to provide extra strength
Cons:
- May get dented easily upon falling
15. Wilton 15 x 21-Inch 2105-0109 Cookie Pan
The Wilton 15”x21” cookie sheet is a behemoth when compared to most others on this list.
Gauge
The sheet is made from heavy gauge, stainless steel and is great for using in high temperatures of up to 450°F. It is warp resistant and can be used in the dishwasher. Despite its size, the cookie sheet is not heavy and can be lifted by one person alone. It is also safe for use in freezers in temperatures as low as -40°F.
Size
Th dimension of this sheet are 15”x21” and it is not made for the regular home ovens. The sheet requires a large oven and is great for professional kitchens and cafés. The sheet’s size is also standard for baking contests and it can be used for baking a large batch of cookies whenever needed.
Material
The sheet is made from high grade stainless steel and is warp and rust resistant. It can be used in high temperatures repeatedly and is also food safe. The baking sheet is covered by a thin coat of non-stick coating and it makes it perfect for easy cookie removal and easy cleanup.
Rim Type
The cookie sheet has shallow rims which can help in braising your food from time to time, however, is not good for baking cakes and brownies. The rim will prevent small amounts of juices from flowing over into your oven and should not be trusted with juicy recipes.
Usability
The sheet is exclusively for baking cookies and similar recipes, however i9t can be used for braising from time to time.
Pros:
- High-grade steel and warp resistant
- Works well in temperatures up to 450°F
- Can bake large batches of cookies
- Has a think non-stick coating
Cons:
- Size not suitable for most ovens
